Cartier’s consistent quality and unique design choices have earned them a well-respected reputation and deemed them a household name in the watch industry. They have an unapologetic commitment to making each piece stand out in a way that embodies the nature of their brand, making their watches highly regarded and valuable.
With this undeniable quality comes those who desire the identical look of a Cartier piece without having to pay full price for authenticity. Cartier has been one of the primary victims of counterfeiting, and unfortunately, it’s not always easy to differentiate a true Cartier watch from a fake one.
It takes a keen eye and specific attention to detail to spot the blemishes or the cut corners counterfeiters tend to take. In this article, we will explore all of the ways that you can spot a fake Cartier to know exactly what you are purchasing and how legitimate it may be.
The Telltale Signs of a Fake Cartier Watch
Cartier fakes will always try to mirror the original design to the best of their ability, but when thoroughly expected, you can usually tell the difference as to which one is real as long as you know what to look for.
No matter how hard they try, fakes will never meet the Cartier standard, but a highly skilled counterfeiter can come very close and, to the untrained eye, could very well pass a fake along as a true Cartier piece.
That’s why it is extremely important to do your research and be observant to be confident that what you’re buying is the real deal. A few of the trademark signs of an authentic Cartier watch include:
Roman Numerals
Cartier dials usually include bold, black Roman numerals, which perfectly contrast their white or silver backgrounds. The legibility of these select pieces makes them recognizable as authentic Cartier watches, as the counterfeits either don’t include Roman numerals or, if they do, they are of significantly less quality or in a different font.
Case Back, Serial numbers, Stamping, Hallmarks
If you turn your Cartier watch over, the brand name will be spelled in clear and elegant letters, identifying the watch as legitimate. The serial number lies directly below the brand name, which is unique to every watch manufactured, and modern Cartier watches have a four-digit number as well, which is the case reference.
Along with the numbers, you can also see important stamping indicating the movement and make of the watch. If the watch were automatic, it would tell you on the stamping, and if it were made of stainless steel, it would tell you that as well.
Screws
Screws are one of the most tell-tale signs of a fake. Cartier watches never use Phillips-head screws, so if you are looking for a real watch, look for flathead screws only. Oftentimes, counterfeiters will use Phillips head screws or, even worse; they won’t use screws at all and just place stickers of flathead screws to make you think it’s a real piece.
A good way to decipher what’s real or not is to get a screwdriver and see for yourself. Remember, no X screws, and if you do use a screwdriver, always be extremely careful not to scratch the case back.
Are Fake Cartier Watches Worth It?
With all the controversy around fake watches and how to tell the real from the counterfeit, I suppose the only question remaining is whether fakes are worth it or if they are truly scams through and through.
Many obvious fakes will prove to be pieces of junk. I speak from personal experience—all I can tell you is don’t purchase fake Rolexes from street vendors in Italy; they will break the very next day.
Not all counterfeit watches are of the same quality, however. While most fakes can never hope to achieve the level of quality as the higher-name brands they attempt to emulate, they can still hold their own and prove to be sustainable pieces that can perform all of the tasks needed in a standard watch.
If you can find a well-made fake, then you could even pass it off as a name-brand, impressing those who see it, all while paying a fraction of the cost.
It is risky, however. Again, while I knew the Rolex I bought for 10 euros in Italy was fake, I had no idea it would break the next day. Well-made fakes are watches that can last. They will be slower, they won’t be made with the same materials, and there will be blemishes implying that this is not a Cartier or a Rolex, but—hopefully—they will function well enough for a long period of time. It’s difficult to recommend, though. In the watch world, you truly pay for what you get.
Big names like Cartier are expensive, to be sure, but there is good reason for the price they demand. You can’t find anything like a true Cartier piece. The level of craftsmanship will be evident on every square inch of the binding and case, with perfectly polished materials glimmering like treasure as it sits proudly on your wrist. Not to mention the mechanical quality. Flawless movement is a staple of authenticity as well.
You can’t expect that kind of intricacy from a fake—no matter how skilled the counterfeiter may be. It seems to me that Cartier fakes specifically are not the kind of watches you want to be looking for. Counterfeiters seem to cut far too many corners when it comes to replicating Cartier’s, leading to a drastic drop in quality and, in some cases, being unwearable.
Using stickers to look like screws is an immediate red flag that should set off an alarm in your head to steer clear of anything that resembles a scam, and some are quite frankly very ugly and look nothing like an authentic Cartier.
Overall, I can’t recommend fakes; it’s simply too risky. If you are on a budget, just don’t go looking for high-name brands that you know are more expensive. My best recommendation would be to simply look for a cheaper watch and avoid trying to get people’s attention by resorting to a potential scam.
There are plenty of high-quality watches that are perfect for a budget. If you are looking for a piece with the sole purpose of trying to impress anyone who sees you wearing it, then you are going about it wrong. Instead, focus on how the watches are made and look for what suits you. This will lead to a deeper understanding of the craft and will cause you to more accurately acknowledge what fits you best. Trust me, there are plenty of pieces out there just waiting to be discovered.
How to Avoid Getting a Fake Cartier Watch
We discussed briefly how to tell if your Cartier is fake or not. The Roman numerals, case back, serial numbers, stamping, and hallmarks are all good ways to tell, with the screws on the case back being the most obvious hint that your watch is fake.
Another common design feature is the blue hands that perfectly match Cartier’s signature blue “cabochon,” a polished gemstone capping the mechanism that winds to the right.
Another important feature of a Cartier watch is its weight. Genuine Cartiers are crafted from pure materials like gold, platinum, or stainless steel. All these materials carry a signature weight, indicating the quality and authenticity while also signifying just how top-of-the-line Cartier pieces are.
If you were to hold an authentic Cartier in your hand, you would undoubtedly notice the satisfying heft that it carries. The weight should feel proportional to the size of the watch, with fake Cartiers typically being made with lightweight alloys that feel all wrong in your hand.
Because of this, fakes are much lighter than authentic Cartiers due to their cheap attempt to replicate premium materials. In order to properly assess the weight to ensure what you have in your hand is the real deal, it helps to compare it to a known authentic Cartier of the same model.
Remember, fake Cartier watches will appear much lighter than authentic ones, and if you ever get a chance to compare the two side by side, it would benefit you greatly to do so, as you can never be too sure.
One critical method of examining Cartier’s attention to detail is to study its dials. Genuine Cartier dials are renowned worldwide by watch enthusiasts for their precise printing, legible markers, and iconic Roman numerals.
Authentic Cartier timepieces feature evenly spaced text and numerals that are very precise and proportional, aligning in perfect symmetry with the rest of the dial. The printing should be sharp, with no signs of blurring or smudging, and there should be no inconsistencies anywhere on the dial. Depending on the specific models, there may be a combination of Roman numerals and stick markers, with each complimenting the other in a geometrically pleasing way.
Counterfeit dials often fail to meet the pristine standards of authentic pieces. In most cases, the printing appears blurry and inconsistent, with misaligned numerals and markers improperly spaced. The numerals may have incorrect shapes or sizes as well, and oftentimes, they will be printed using a format that contradicts Cartier’s official font.
The quality of the hands comes into play as well. Genuine Cartier’s have hands that are finely crafted and perfectly proportioned to the dial, with smooth finishing and a fluid movement that emulates the flawless mechanics propelling them. Fake watches have hands that are poorly finished. Some are even bent or do not align correctly with the markers.
Authentic Cartier watches prioritize high-quality, scratch-resistant sapphire crystal glass to enhance the durability of the watch and add to the overall luxury and pristine craftsmanship. When looking at a Cartier, be sure to examine the quality and condition of the glass to determine whether or not it comes from authentic Cartier manufacturers.
Sapphire crystal glass is known to be extremely resistant to scratches. It’s a synthetic material and is up there with pure diamond in terms of its Mohs scale hardness. This makes it so true Cartier watches are highly unlikely to scratch under typical wearing conditions, ensuring that the watch’s integrity is preserved over extended periods. True Cartier glass will look flawless and will reflect light beautifully, while fakes will more than likely have blemishes and scratches that will appear obvious if you look hard enough.
Because of the inferior glass materials—such as plastic or mineral crystal—the fakes are far more likely to fall victim to extreme wear and damage, with the glass being worn down faster than authentic Cartier’s. You will quickly notice the aesthetic of fake glass as time goes on because fake materials are far less durable than the real thing.
In order to test the quality of the glass, gently rub a soft cloth over the surface. If it is smooth and resistant, it is an authentic sapphire crystal; if it is softer or if it scratches, it is most likely a fake. Obviously, use extreme caution when practicing this method. Sapphire glass is strong, but there is always a risk of scratching an authentic Cartier as well.
Conclusion
There is a reason that Cartier watches are widely recognized as one of the top watch brands. They have spent decades perfecting their craft, ensuring every region of every piece is flawlessly tuned and polished so that their customers always know exactly what they are putting on their wrists.
Everyone that has experience with Cartier watches knows just how pristine their craftsmanship is. While good fakes can be difficult to spot with an untrained eye, once you closely examine the ways in which a real and a fake differ, it is painstakingly obvious which one has been labored over more.
Cartier captures a particular magic that you can’t quite recreate, and any attempt to do so is an insult to each artist who has dedicated their life to this craft, ensuring their customers are getting the highest quality timepiece that will last them a lifetime.